Page 1 of 1

Textbook Problem Chp 4 #9

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 3:51 pm
by Jade Fosburgh Discussion 2C
4.9 (a) What is the shape of an ICl3 molecule (iodine is the central atom)

I drew the Lewis structure and made sure the formal charge was equal to zero for all atoms. Iodine had 2 lone pairs of e- and 1 single bond to each Cl. Therefore, since there were 5 regions of electron density, the electron arrangement was trigonal bipyramidal. However, we must account for the two lone pairs. The solutions said the molecule would be T-shaped, with an angle of <90 degrees. However, why wouldn't it be a trigonal planar shape, with a bond angle of <120 degrees? I imagined the lone pairs being arranged on opposite sides of the atom. Wouldn't that be more favorable since the e'-s would be farther apart?

Re: Textbook Problem Chp 4 #9

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 4:07 pm
by Bansi Amin 1D
Trigonal planar is AX3 while the ICl3 molecule is AX3E2 which is what T- shaped is.

Re: Textbook Problem Chp 4 #9

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 4:11 pm
by Janine Chan 2K
In a trigonal planar shape, there are only 3 bonding pairs surrounding the central atom. As you drew in your Lewis structure, ICl3 has 3 bonding pairs and 2 lone pairs, which would make it T-shaped.

Re: Textbook Problem Chp 4 #9

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 4:27 pm
by Emily Mei 1B
The shape is trigonal planar because you determine molecular shape by the number of bonding pairs on the central atom. When you then factor in the lone pairs, they bonded e- and lone pair e- repel each other and the molecular shape becomes T-shaped, changing the angle to less than 90ยบ.