6c.19 f

[Fdonovan 3D]

Which is the strongest acid, H2CO3 or H2GeO3? (Justify your answer)

In the answer key, it says H2CO3 is the stronger acid because C is more electronegative. However, I thought that when comparing acids in which the only difference is the central atom, you compare the bond strengths for elements in the same group. Since Ge and C come from the same group (not the same period), shouldn't the justification come from comparing the bond strengths, not the electronegativity?

[Ethan Lam 4A]

Electronegativity and bond strengths both play a factor in determining acid strength. Since it is more electronegative, it becomes more polar which makes it easier to dissociate.

[Ruby Richter 2L]

So, in this case, the difference in electronegativity would dominate over the difference in bond strength?